I went for the first time last week. The place was great very nice and rooms were clean. The pool was open and the hot tub was great. Had two great experiences.
It's hit or miss depending on the day of week and time of day you're there. The "Dark Room" is always fun as long as there are others there.
A couple points: Their "Day Pass $8.00" is really a one-day membership. That is, you DON'T need a membership to enter. You'll just pay $8.00 extra each time you go in for the day.
I really enjoy Club Indianapolis. Plenty of men who are willing to let me suck their cocks. The out-of-towners always seem surprised when I ask if they would like their cocks sucked, and very few of them turn me down. All in all, a great place!