I called the old number, and got a recording that gave me the new number: 765.426-9222.

Called it and asked if they were still open. She said they moved to 3102 E Main, Bloomfield, IN. I asked if that was close to Fishers, and she said yes. (Ummm- Bloomfield is near Bloomington!) I asked if Jenny was there, she said she might come back, but there were 2 girls there.

WAIT A MINUTE!

Minutes after posting this, I saw an ad in Nuvo for Lilly's, with the same address... but in PLAINFIELD, not Bloomfield! The ad has 317.838-0661 listed as the new number. She needs to work on pronouncing PLAINFIELD!